$@!!(J$@!!(J$@!!(J$@A1(J$@$-(J$@@8(J$@$N(J$@CO(J$@J?(J$@$H(J$@$7(J$@$F(J$@$N(J$@6&(J$@F1(J$@BN(J$@!a(J$@@/(J$@<#(J$@E*(J$@8x(J$@6&(J$@@-(J
$@!!(J$@!!(J$@!!(J$@!!(J$@!!(J$@!!(J$@!X(J$@E/(J$@3X(J$@O@(J$@=8(J$@!Y(J$@Bh(J$@#2(J$@#5(J$@9f(J$@!J(J$@#1(J$@#9(J$@#9(J$@#6(J$@G/(J$@!"(J$@>e(J$@CR(J$@Bg(J$@3X(J$@E/(J$@3X(J$@2q(J$@!K(J$@7G(J$@:\(J
$@EZ(J$@66(J$@!!(J$@LP(J$@
1. $@CO(J$@0h(J$@ $@!J(J$@Cp(J1$@!K(J Cf. P. Pettit, Liberal/Communitarian: MacIntyre's Mesmeric Dichotomy, in: After MacIntyre, Cambridge/Oxford, 1994, pp.176-204. $@$?(J$@$@(J$@$7(J$@!"(JPettit $@$O(J$@$3(J$@$&(J$@$7(J$@$?(J$@Fs(J$@85(J$@O@(J$@E*(J$@9=(J$@?^(J$@$N(J$@IT(J$@LS(J$@@-(J$@$r(J$@9n(J$@I~(J$@$9(J$@$k(J$@Bh(J$@;0(J$@$N(J$@ES(J$@$H(J$@$7(J$@$F(J republicanism $@$r(J$@>N(J$@MH(J$@$7(J$@$F(J$@$$(J$@$k(J$@!#(J Copyright : Shigeki Tsuchihashi 1996 $@!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!(J
$@!!(J$@$^(J$@$:(J$@Ev(J$@3:(J$@$N(J$@=8(J$@CD(J$@AH(J$@?%(J$@$,(J$@<+(J$@A3(J$@E*(J$@!&(J$@<+(J$@F/(J$@E*(J$@$G(J$@$"(J$@$k(J$@$+(J$@?M(J$@0Y(J$@E*(J$@!&(J$@5,(J$@Ls(J$@E*(J$@$G(J$@$"(J$@$k(J$@$+(J$@$r(J$@0l(J$@J}(J$@$N(J$@:B(J$@I8(J$@<4(J$@$K(J$@!"(J$@Ev(J$@3:(J$@=8(J$@CD(J$@$N(J$@@-(J$@3J(J$@$,(J$@6q(J$@BN(J$@E*(J$@!&(J$@?M(J$@3J(J$@E*(J$@!&(J$@Mx(J$@B>(J$@E*(J$@$G(J$@$"(J$@$k(J$@$+(J$@!"(J$@Cj(J$@>](J$@E*(J$@!&(J$@Hs(J$@?M(J$@3J(J$@E*(J$@!&(J$@Mx(J$@8J(J$@E*(J$@$G(J$@$"(J$@$k(J$@$+(J$@$r(J$@B>(J$@J}(J$@$N(J$@:B(J$@I8(J$@<4(J$@$K(J$@?x(J$@$((J$@$k(J$@$3(J$@$H(J$@$K(J$@$h(J$@$C(J$@$F(J$@!"(J$@0J(J$@2<(J$@$N(J$@#4(J$@$D(J$@$N(J$@>](J$@8B(J$@$r(J$@Cj(J$@=P(J$@$7(J$@$F(J$@$_(J$@$k(J$@!#(J
$@!J(Ji$@!K6qBNE*$+$D<+A3E*?M4V4X78!'@.0w$K6&DL$9$k2ACM$N%R%(%i%k%-!<$,$"$j!"F10lL\E*$N<+H/E*DI5a$,2DG=$JItB2
$@!J(Jiii$@!KCj>]E*$+$D5,LsE*?M4V4X78!'@/<#$K$*$1$k6/@)86M}$K4p$E$/;YG[4X78!#(J
$@!J(Jiv$@!K6qBNE*$+$D5,LsE*?M4V4X78!'@.0w4V$N<+M3$JAj8_I^=u$K4p$E$/%M%C%H%o!<%-%s%0!#(J
$@!!$3$l$i$r8=Be@/<#;WA[$N=tD,N.$K4XO"$E$1$k$J$i!"!J(Jiii$@!K$r=E;k$9$k$N$,%8%g%s!&%m!<%k%:!"%m%J%k%I!&%I%%%*!<%-%s$r;O$a$H$9$k$$$o$f$kJ!;c7?<+M3
$@!!(J$@K\(J$@9F(J$@$G(J$@$O(J$@!"(J$@0J(J$@>e(J$@$r(J$@F'(J$@$^(J$@$((J$@$J(J$@$,(J$@$i(J$@!"(J$@$+(J$@$D(J$@$F(J$@6&(J$@F1(J$@BN(J$@$,(J$@3F(J$@@.(J$@0w(J$@$K(J$@$H(J$@$C(J$@$F(J$@A1(J$@$/(J$@@8(J$@$-(J$@$k(J$@$?(J$@$a(J$@$N(J$@6q(J$@BN(J$@E*(J$@$J(J$@8x(J$@6&(J$@E*(J$@CO(J$@J?(J$@$?(J$@$j(J$@F@(J$@$?(J$@E@(J$@$K(J$@Ce(J$@L\(J$@$7(J$@!"(J$@$=(J$@$&(J$@$7(J$@$?(J$@A1(J$@$N(J$@8x(J$@6&(J$@E*(J$@CO(J$@J?(J$@$,(J$@;W(J$@A[(J$@;K(J$@$K(J$@$*(J$@$$(J$@$F(J$@$$(J$@$+(J$@$K(J$@$7(J$@$F(J$@<:(J$@$o(J$@$l(J$@$F(J$@$$(J$@$C(J$@$?(J$@$+(J$@$r(J$@35(J$@4Q(J$@$7(J$@$?(J$@>e(J$@$G(J$@!"(J$@
2. $@$7(J$@$+(J$@$7(J$@!"(J$@K\(J$@Bj(J$@$K(J$@F~(J$@$k(J$@A0(J$@$K(J$@$^(J$@$:(J$@:G(J$@=i(J$@$K(J$@L@(J$@3N(J$@$K(J$@$7(J$@$F(J$@$*(J$@$-(J$@$?(J$@$$(J$@$3(J$@$H(J$@$O(J$@!"(J$@6&(J$@F1(J$@BN(J$@
$@!!(J$@$5(J$@$F(J$@!J(J$@$"(J$@$/(J$@$^(J$@$G(J$@#M(J$@!&(J$@%&(J$@%)(J$@%k(J$@%D(J$@%!(J$@!<(J$@!J(J$@Cp(J8$@!K(J$@$N(J$@2<(J$@$7(J$@$?(J$@?G(J$@CG(J$@$K(J$@>h(J$@$C(J$@$+(J$@$C(J$@$F(J$@8@(J$@$&(J$@$J(J$@$i(J$@$P(J$@!K(J$@$=(J$@$b(J$@$=(J$@$b(J$@%3(J$@%_(J$@%e(J$@%K(J$@%?(J$@%j(J$@%"(J$@%s(J$@!J(J$@6&(J$@F1(J$@BN(J$@O@(J$@
$@!!(J$@$G(J$@$O(J$@!"(J$@6&(J$@F1(J$@BN(J$@O@(J$@
3. $@$^(J$@$:(J$@!"(J$@8E(J$@Be(J$@%.(J$@%j(J$@%7(J$@%"(J$@$N(J$@%"(J$@%j(J$@%9(J$@%H(J$@%F(J$@%l(J$@%9(J$@$K(J$@$5(J$@$+(J$@$N(J$@$\(J$@$m(J$@$&(J$@!#(J$@H`(J$@$K(J$@$h(J$@$l(J$@$P(J$@!"(J$@?M(J$@4V(J$@$O(J$@$=(J$@$N(J$@<+(J$@A3(J$@K\(J$@@-(J$@$K(J$@$7(J$@$?(J$@$,(J$@$C(J$@$F(J$@8_(J$@$$(J$@$K(J$@8r(J$@N.(J$@$7(J$@!"(J$@CK(J$@!&(J$@=w(J$@!"(J$@
$@!!(J$@$7(J$@$+(J$@$7(J$@!"(J$@%"(J$@%j(J$@%9(J$@%H(J$@%F(J$@%l(J$@%9(J$@E*(J$@@/(J$@<#(J$@E*(J$@8x(J$@6&(J$@@-(J$@$N(J$@M}(J$@G0(J$@$O(J$@!"(J$@$=(J$@$N(J$@M}(J$@O@(J$@GX(J$@7J(J$@$H(J$@$b(J$@$J(J$@$C(J$@$F(J$@$$(J$@$?(J$@Nr(J$@;K(J$@E*(J$@=j(J$@M?(J$@$G(J$@$"(J$@$k(J$@%](J$@%j(J$@%9(J$@$N(J$@Jx(J$@2u(J$@$r(J$@$b(J$@$C(J$@$F(J$@;v(J$@e(J$@>C(J$@LG(J$@$X(J$@$N(J$@ES(J$@$r(J$@$?(J$@$I(J$@$C(J$@$?(J$@!#(J$@$^(J$@$:(J$@;~(J$@Be(J$@$,(J$@%X(J$@%l(J$@%K(J$@%:(J$@%`(J$@4|(J$@$K(J$@0\(J$@9T(J$@$9(J$@$k(J$@$H(J$@!"(J$@EA(J$@E}(J$@E*(J$@%](J$@%j(J$@%9(J$@E*(J$@2A(J$@CM(J$@4Q(J$@$N(J$@AS(J$@<:(J$@$K(J$@H<(J$@$$(J$@!"(J$@0l(J$@J}(J$@$N(J$@%"(J$@%+(J$@%G(J$@%a(J$@%$(J$@%"(J$@$G(J$@$O(J$@2{(J$@5?(J$@O@(J$@$,(J$@??(J$@7u(J$@$J(J$@F$(J$@5D(J$@$N(J$@E*(J$@$H(J$@$J(J$@$j(J$@!"(J$@B>(J$@J}(J$@%9(J$@%H(J$@%"(J$@3X(J$@GI(J$@$d(J$@%((J$@%T(J$@%/(J$@%m(J$@%9(J$@3X(J$@GI(J$@$K(J$@$*(J$@$$(J$@$F(J$@$O(J$@!"(J$@%W(J$@%i(J$@%H(J$@%s(J$@$N(J$@>'(J$@$((J$@$?(J$@A1(J$@$N(J$@%$(J$@%G(J$@%"(J$@$X(J$@$N(J$@4Q(J$@A[(J$@E*(J$@D6(J$@1[(J$@$N(J$@ES(J$@$b(J$@<+(J$@$i(J$@$N(J$@M#(J$@J*(J$@O@(J$@$N(J$@$f(J$@$((J$@$K(J$@CG(J$@G0(J$@$5(J$@$l(J$@!"(J$@%"(J$@%j(J$@%9(J$@%H(J$@%F(J$@%l(J$@%9(J$@$N(J$@$?(J$@$F(J$@$?(J$@@/(J$@<#(J$@E*(J$@8x(J$@6&(J$@@-(J$@$K(J$@$*(J$@$1(J$@$k(J$@8=(J$@@$(J$@E*(J$@<+(J$@8J(J$@c(J$@$5(J$@$l(J$@$k(J$@NN(J$@0h(J$@$,(J$@!V(J$@2f(J$@!9(J$@$N(J$@
$@!!(J$@Dk(J$@@/(J$@4|(J$@%m(J$@!<(J$@%^(J$@$K(J$@F~(J$@$k(J$@$H(J$@!"(J$@%](J$@%j(J$@%9(J$@$N(J$@?j(J$@B`(J$@$K(J$@H<(J$@$&(J$@@/(J$@<#(J$@E*(J$@8x(J$@6&(J$@@-(J$@$N(J$@8e(J$@B`(J$@$H(J$@!"(J$@$=(J$@$l(J$@$K(J$@H?(J$@Hf(J$@Nc(J$@$9(J$@$k(J$@;d(J$@E*(J$@NN(J$@0h(J$@$N(J$@?J(J$@=P(J$@$N(J$@7k(J$@2L(J$@!"(J$@%m(J$@!<(J$@%^(J$@=t(J$@ET(J$@;T(J$@$O(J$@!"(J$@%.(J$@%j(J$@%7(J$@%"(J$@!&(J$@%](J$@%j(J$@%9(J$@$,(J$@FC(J$@8"(J$@E*(J$@$J(J$@<+(J$@M3(J$@;T(J$@L1(J$@$K(J$@$h(J$@$k(J$@>C(J$@Hq(J$@@8(J$@3h(J$@$r(J$@@l(J$@$i(J$@$H(J$@$7(J$@!"(J$@@8(J$@;:(J$@3h(J$@F0(J$@$d(J$@>&(J$@6H(J$@3h(J$@F0(J$@$N(J$@0l(J$@@Z(J$@$r(J$@;d(J$@E*(J$@NN(J$@0h(J$@!J(J$@$9(J$@$J(J$@$o(J$@$A(J$@2H(J$@@/(J$@!K(J$@$K(J$@?6(J$@$j(J$@J,(J$@$1(J$@$?(J$@$N(J$@$K(J$@BP(J$@$7(J$@!"(J$@$`(J$@$7(J$@$m(J$@@8(J$@;:(J$@!&(J$@>&(J$@6H(J$@3h(J$@F0(J$@$N(J$@Cf(J$@?4(J$@$K(J$@$J(J$@$C(J$@$F(J$@$$(J$@$C(J$@$?(J$@!J(J$@Cp(J14$@!K(J$@!#(J$@%"(J$@%j(J$@%9(J$@%H(J$@%F(J$@%l(J$@%9(J$@E*(J$@$J(J$@0U(J$@L#(J$@$G(J$@$N(J$@8x(J$@E*(J$@NN(J$@0h(J$@$O(J$@%-(J$@%j(J$@%9(J$@%H(J$@65(J$@$,(J$@C4(J$@$C(J$@$?(J$@$,(J$@!"(J$@A}(J$@Bg(J$@$9(J$@$k(J$@;d(J$@E*(J$@NN(J$@0h(J$@!J(J$@2H(J$@@/(J$@$N(J$@3H(J$@D%(J$@7A(J$@BV(J$@$H(J$@$7(J$@$F(J$@$N(J$@
$@!!(J$@$=(J$@$N(J$@$3(J$@$H(J$@$r(J$@;W(J$@A[(J$@LL(J$@$+(J$@$i(J$@8+(J$@$F(J$@$_(J$@$h(J$@$&(J$@!#(J$@$^(J$@$:(J$@!"(J$@0l(J$@;0(J$@@$(J$@5*(J$@$K(J$@%"(J$@%j(J$@%9(J$@%H(J$@%F(J$@%l(J$@%9(J$@$N(J$@!X(J$@@/(J$@<#(J$@3X(J$@!Y(J$@$N(J$@%i(J$@%F(J$@%s(J$@8l(J$@Lu(J$@$,(J$@%h(J$@!<(J$@%m(J$@%C(J$@%Q(J$@$K(J$@=i(J$@$a(J$@$F(J$@EP(J$@>l(J$@$9(J$@$k(J$@$K(J$@5Z(J$@$s(J$@$G(J$@!"(J$@@/(J$@<#(J$@E*(J$@;Y(J$@G[(J$@$N(J$@@5(J$@Ev(J$@@-(J$@$,(J$@%-(J$@%j(J$@%9(J$@%H(J$@65(J$@E*(J$@$J(J$@8"(J$@0R(J$@H4(J$@$-(J$@$G(J$@!"(J$@?M(J$@4V(J$@$N(J$@<+(J$@A3(J$@K\(J$@@-(J$@$+(J$@$i(J$@O@(J$@>Z(J$@$5(J$@$l(J$@$k(J$@$h(J$@$&(J$@$K(J$@$J(J$@$C(J$@$?(J$@!#(J$@@/(J$@<#(J$@3X(J$@$N(J$@<+(J$@N'(J$@$G(J$@$"(J$@$k(J$@!#(J$@$3(J$@$l(J$@$O(J$@!"(J$@:#(J$@$^(J$@$G(J$@$N(J$@%"(J$@%&(J$@%0(J$@%9(J$@%F(J$@%#(J$@%L(J$@%9(J$@E*(J$@
$@!!(J$@$=(J$@$N(J$@$h(J$@$&(J$@$J(J$@F0(J$@8~(J$@$K(J$@Go(J$@
$@!!(J$@$5(J$@$F(J$@6a(J$@Be(J$@$K(J$@F~(J$@$C(J$@$F(J$@%[(J$@%C(J$@%V(J$@%:(J$@$d(J$@%m(J$@%C(J$@%/(J$@$K(J$@$J(J$@$k(J$@$H(J$@!"(J$@;d(J$@E*(J$@NN(J$@0h(J$@$H(J$@8x(J$@E*(J$@NN(J$@0h(J$@$O(J$@$b(J$@$C(J$@$H(J$@1T(J$@$$(J$@BP(J$@N)(J$@$r(J$@8+(J$@$;(J$@;O(J$@$a(J$@$k(J$@!#(J$@<+(J$@8J(J$@J](J$@B8(J$@$H(J$@$$(J$@$&(J$@<+(J$@A3(J$@8"(J$@$K(J$@$h(J$@$C(J$@$F(J$@8D(J$@?M(J$@$r(J$@J](J$@8n(J$@$9(J$@$k(J$@;d(J$@E*(J$@NN(J$@0h(J$@$,(J$@$b(J$@$?(J$@$i(J$@$5(J$@$l(J$@!"(J$@$5(J$@$i(J$@$K(J$@O+(J$@F/(J$@$K(J$@$h(J$@$C(J$@$F(J$@F@(J$@$i(J$@$l(J$@$?(J$@=j(J$@M-(J$@$H(J$@$$(J$@$&(J$@7A(J$@$G(J$@;d(J$@E*(J$@NN(J$@0h(J$@$,(J$@3H(J$@D%(J$@$5(J$@$l(J$@$F(J$@$$(J$@$/(J$@$,(J$@!"(J$@$=(J$@$l(J$@$K(J$@BP(J$@$7(J$@$F(J$@8x(J$@E*(J$@NN(J$@0h(J$@$O(J$@8x(J$@8"(J$@NO(J$@$H(J$@$7(J$@$F(J$@$"(J$@$/(J$@$^(J$@$G(J$@;d(J$@E*(J$@NN(J$@0h(J$@$K(J$@?/(J$@F~(J$@$9(J$@$k(J$@$b(J$@$N(J$@$H(J$@$7(J$@$F(J$@B*(J$@$((J$@$i(J$@$l(J$@$F(J$@$$(J$@$/(J$@!#(J$@$7(J$@$+(J$@$b(J$@!"(J$@=!(J$@65(J$@@o(J$@Ah(J$@$K(J$@$*(J$@$1(J$@$k(J$@42(J$@MF(J$@$N(J$@@:(J$@?@(J$@$+(J$@$i(J$@!"(J$@A1(J$@$=(J$@$N(J$@$b(J$@$N(J$@$r(J$@Ld(J$@$&(J$@$3(J$@$H(J$@$N(J$@2s(J$@Hr(J$@$,(J$@@8(J$@$8(J$@!"(J$@A1(J$@$r(J$@;X(J$@8~(J$@$9(J$@$k(J$@2A(J$@CM(J$@CO(J$@J?(J$@$H(J$@$7(J$@$F(J$@$N(J$@8x(J$@6&(J$@@-(J$@$N(J$@I,(J$@MW(J$@@-(J$@$^(J$@$G(J$@$b(J$@$,(J$@H](J$@Dj(J$@$5(J$@$l(J$@$k(J$@$K(J$@;j(J$@$C(J$@$?(J$@!#(J$@$b(J$@$O(J$@$d(J$@8x(J$@8"(J$@NO(J$@$O(J$@2?(J$@$i(J$@$N(J$@4K(J$@>W(J$@NN(J$@0h(J$@$b(J$@7P(J$@$:(J$@$K(J$@D>(J$@@\(J$@!"(J$@;d(J$@E*(J$@NN(J$@0h(J$@$r(J$@?;(J$@?)(J$@$7(J$@;O(J$@$a(J$@$?(J$@$N(J$@$G(J$@$"(J$@$k(J$@!#(J
$@!!(J$@$@(J$@$,(J$@$3(J$@$&(J$@$7(J$@$?(J$@8x(J$@;d(J$@$N(J$@L@(J$@3N(J$@$J(J$@BP(J$@N)(J$@$r(J$@G^(J$@2p(J$@$9(J$@$k(J$@$b(J$@$N(J$@$H(J$@$7(J$@$F(J$@!"(J$@0l(J$@H,(J$@@$(J$@5*(J$@0J(J$@9_(J$@!"(J$@J8(J$@7](J$@E*(J$@8x(J$@6&(J$@@-(J$@$,(J$@@/(J$@<#(J$@E*(J$@8x(J$@6&(J$@@-(J$@$N(J$@2D(J$@G=(J$@@-(J$@$r(J$@Ds(J$@6!(J$@$9(J$@$k(J$@$h(J$@$&(J$@$K(J$@$J(J$@$k(J$@!#(J$@$3(J$@$N(J$@J8(J$@7](J$@E*(J$@8x(J$@6&(J$@@-(J$@$H(J$@$O(J$@!"(J$@@8(J$@;:(J$@!&(J$@>C(J$@Hq(J$@3h(J$@F0(J$@$,(J$@9T(J$@$o(J$@$l(J$@$k(J$@;d(J$@E*(J$@NN(J$@0h(J$@$+(J$@$i(J$@$b(J$@!"(J$@8x(J$@8"(J$@NO(J$@$,(J$@9T(J$@;H(J$@$5(J$@$l(J$@$k(J$@8x(J$@E*(J$@NN(J$@0h(J$@$+(J$@$i(J$@$b(J$@6h(J$@JL(J$@$5(J$@$l(J$@!"(J$@$=(J$@$l(J$@$i(J$@$N(J$@Cf(J$@4V(J$@NN(J$@0h(J$@$H(J$@$7(J$@$F(J$@!"(J$@F$(J$@5D(J$@!&(J$@?3(J$@5D(J$@$7(J$@9g(J$@$&(J$@;T(J$@L1(J$@$?(J$@$A(J$@$N(J$@6&(J$@F1(J$@0U(J$@;W(J$@$K(J$@4p(J$@$E(J$@$$(J$@$F(J$@$=(J$@$3(J$@$K(J$@<+(J$@H/(J$@E*(J$@6&(J$@F1(J$@
$@!!(J$@0J(J$@>e(J$@$N(J$@$h(J$@$&(J$@$K(J$@!"(J$@$+(J$@$D(J$@$F(J$@8x(J$@E*(J$@NN(J$@0h(J$@$K(J$@M}(J$@G0(J$@$H(J$@$7(J$@$F(J$@51(J$@$$(J$@$F(J$@$$(J$@$?(J$@@/(J$@<#(J$@E*(J$@8x(J$@6&(J$@@-(J$@$O(J$@!"(J$@;d(J$@E*(J$@NN(J$@0h(J$@$N(J$@3H(J$@Bg(J$@$K(J$@H<(J$@$&(J$@
4. $@$7(J$@$?(J$@$,(J$@$C(J$@$F(J$@0J(J$@2<(J$@$G(J$@$O(J$@!"(J$@6&(J$@F1(J$@BN(J$@$N(J$@@8(J$@$H(J$@8D(J$@?M(J$@$N(J$@;d(J$@E*(J$@$J(J$@@8(J$@$H(J$@$N(J$@E}(J$@9g(J$@!"(J$@$9(J$@$J(J$@$o(J$@$A(J$@8x(J$@E*(J$@$J(J$@@8(J$@$H(J$@;d(J$@E*(J$@$J(J$@@8(J$@$r(J$@G^(J$@2p(J$@$9(J$@$k(J$@8x(J$@6&(J$@@-(J$@$K(J$@$D(J$@$$(J$@$F(J$@9M(J$@$((J$@$F(J$@$_(J$@$k(J$@$3(J$@$H(J$@$K(J$@$9(J$@$k(J$@!#(J
$@!!(J$@6a(J$@Be(J$@$N(J$@7<(J$@LX(J$@$r(J$@7P(J$@$?(J$@8D(J$@?M(J$@$O(J$@!"(J$@<+(J$@J,(J$@$N(J$@$?(J$@$a(J$@$K(J$@!"(J$@<+(J$@J,(J$@$N(J$@9,(J$@J!(J$@$r(J$@G[(J$@N8(J$@$7(J$@$D(J$@$D(J$@9T(J$@0Y(J$@$r(J$@9T(J$@$&(J$@!#(J$@$=(J$@$l(J$@$K(J$@BP(J$@$7(J$@$F(J$@Mx(J$@B>(J$@
$@!!(J$@$=(J$@$l(J$@$K(J$@BP(J$@$7(J$@$F(J$@!"(J$@8D(J$@?M(J$@$N(J$@@8(J$@$H(J$@E}(J$@9g(J$@$5(J$@$l(J$@$k(J$@2H(J$@Dm(J$@$d(J$@?&(J$@>l(J$@!"(J$@3X(J$@9;(J$@!"(J$@M'(J$@?M(J$@4X(J$@78(J$@$J(J$@$I(J$@?H(J$@6a(J$@$G(J$@N.(J$@F0(J$@E*(J$@$+(J$@$D(J$@B?(J$@85(J$@E*(J$@$J(J$@6&(J$@F1(J$@BN(J$@!"(J$@?F(J$@L)(J$@7w(J$@$N(J$@@8(J$@$G(J$@$O(J$@!"(J$@$=(J$@$N(J$@9T(J$@0Y(J$@
$@!!0J>e$+$iL@$i$+$J$3$H$O!"2f!9$,:N$k$Y$-ES$O!"
$@!!(J$@$@(J$@$,(J$@!"(J$@<+(J$@M3(J$@
$@!!(J$@2f(J$@!9(J$@$O(J$@$3(J$@$N(J$@$h(J$@$&(J$@$J(J$@
5. $@$^(J$@$?(J$@!"(J$@$3(J$@$N(J$@$h(J$@$&(J$@$J(J$@E}(J$@9g(J$@E*(J$@6&(J$@F1(J$@BN(J$@$N(J$@I3(J$@BS(J(vinculum)$@$H(J$@$J(J$@$C(J$@$F(J$@$$(J$@$k(J$@$b(J$@$N(J$@$r(J$@!"(J$@:#(J$@2>(J$@$K(J$@8x(J$@6&(J$@E*(J$@%U(J$@%#(J$@%j(J$@%"(J$@!J(J$@M'(J$@0&(J$@!K(J$@$H(J$@8F(J$@$V(J$@$3(J$@$H(J$@$K(J$@$9(J$@$k(J$@!J(J$@Cp(J23$@!K(J$@!#(J$@%"(J$@%j(J$@%9(J$@%H(J$@%F(J$@%l(J$@%9(J$@$K(J$@$h(J$@$l(J$@$P(J$@!"(J$@Mx(J$@B>(J$@0&(J$@$O(J$@!"(J$@FA(J$@$N(J$@$f(J$@$((J$@$K(J$@!"(J$@M'(J$@$N(J$@$?(J$@$a(J$@$K(J$@!"(J$@M'(J$@$K(J$@A1(J$@$r(J$@$J(J$@$9(J$@!"(J$@$H(J$@Dj(J$@<0(J$@2=(J$@$5(J$@$l(J$@$k(J$@$,(J$@!J(J$@Cp(J24$@!K(J$@!"(J$@$=(J$@$N(J$@Dj(J$@<0(J$@$r(J$@8x(J$@6&(J$@E*(J$@%U(J$@%#(J$@%j(J$@%"(J$@$K(J$@N.(J$@MQ(J$@$9(J$@$l(J$@$P(J$@!"(J$@F$(J$@5D(J$@$K(J$@$h(J$@$k(J$@=$(J$@@5(J$@2D(J$@G=(J$@$J(J$@@d(J$@$((J$@$:(J$@;C(J$@Dj(J$@E*(J$@$J(J$@L\(J$@E*(J$@$N(J$@$f(J$@$((J$@$K(J$@!"(J$@6&(J$@F1(J$@BN(J$@$N(J$@$?(J$@$a(J$@$K(J$@!"(J$@6&(J$@F1(J$@BN(J$@$K(J$@A1(J$@$r(J$@$J(J$@$9(J$@!"(J$@$H(J$@$J(J$@$k(J$@$@(J$@$m(J$@$&(J$@!#(J$@E}(J$@9g(J$@E*(J$@6&(J$@F1(J$@BN(J$@$O(J$@!"(J$@$=(J$@$l(J$@<+(J$@?H(J$@$@Cp(J25$@!K(J$@$N(J$@?X(J$@1D(J$@$K(J$@M?(J$@$7(J$@$?(J$@$$(J$@$H(J$@;W(J$@$&(J$@!#(J$@B?(J$@85(J$@
6. $@$7(J$@$+(J$@$7(J$@!"(J$@$3(J$@$N(J$@$h(J$@$&(J$@$K(J$@$7(J$@$F(J$@;d(J$@E*(J$@@8(J$@$,(J$@E}(J$@9g(J$@$5(J$@$l(J$@$?(J$@6&(J$@F1(J$@BN(J$@$O(J$@!"(J$@$^(J$@$?(J$@8x(J$@8"(J$@NO(J$@$N(J$@;d(J$@E*(J$@NN(J$@0h(J$@$X(J$@$N(J$@?;(J$@F)(J$@$r(J$@2D(J$@G=(J$@$H(J$@$9(J$@$k(J$@$b(J$@$N(J$@$G(J$@$b(J$@$"(J$@$k(J$@!J(J$@Cp(J26$@!K(J$@!#(J$@;T(J$@L1(J$@
$@K\(J$@9F(J$@$O(J$@Bh(J$@#4(J$@#3(J$@2s(J$@>e(J$@CR(J$@Bg(J$@3X(J$@E/(J$@3X(J$@2q(J$@!J(J1995$@G/(J10$@7n(J$@!K(J$@%7(J$@%s(J$@%](J$@%8(J$@%&(J$@%`(J$@!V(J$@8=(J$@Be(J$@$K(J$@$*(J$@$1(J$@$k(J$@6&(J$@F1(J$@BN(J$@O@(J$@$N(J$@2D(J$@G=(J$@@-(J$@!W(J$@!J(J$@Ds(J$@Bj(J$@
$@!J(J$@Cp(J2$@!K(J $@;3(J$@:j(J$@@5(J$@OB(J$@!"(J$@O@(J$@CL(J$@;~(J$@I>(J$@!"(J$@D+(J$@F|(J$@?7(J$@J9(J$@!"(J$@J?(J$@@.(J$@H,(J$@G/(J$@;M(J$@7n(J$@;0(J$@!;(J$@F|(J$@!#(J$@0J(J$@A0(J$@!X(J$@=@(J$@$i(J$@$+(J$@$$(J$@8D(J$@?M(J$@
$@!J(J$@Cp(J3$@!K(J $@0l(J$@8}(J$@$K(J$@<+(J$@M3(J$@
$@!J(J$@Cp(J4$@!K(J$@!!(J$@%^(J$@%$(J$@%1(J$@%k(J$@!&(J$@%&(J$@%)(J$@%k(J$@%D(J$@%!(J$@!<(J$@$N(J$@0L(J$@CV(J$@$E(J$@$1(J$@$O(J$@Hy(J$@L/(J$@$G(J$@$"(J$@$j(J$@!"(J$@H`(J$@$r(J$@%3(J$@%_(J$@%e(J$@%K(J$@%?(J$@%j(J$@%"(J$@%s(J$@$H(J$@$_(J$@$J(J$@$9(J$@O@(J$@
$@!J(J$@Cp(J5$@!K(J$@!!(J$@%"(J$@!<(J$@%l(J$@%s(J$@%H(J$@$O(J$@;~(J$@$K(J$@%3(J$@%_(J$@%e(J$@%K(J$@%?(J$@%j(J$@%"(J$@%s(J$@$H(J$@$_(J$@$J(J$@$5(J$@$l(J$@$k(J$@$3(J$@$H(J$@$,(J$@$"(J$@$k(J$@$,(J$@!"(J$@$=(J$@$l(J$@$O(J$@8m(J$@$j(J$@$G(J$@$"(J$@$k(J$@!#(J$@$J(J$@$<(J$@$J(J$@$i(J$@!"(J$@H`(J$@=w(J$@$,(J$@9=(J$@A[(J$@$9(J$@$k(J$@@/(J$@<#(J$@E*(J$@8x(J$@6&(J$@@-(J$@$O(J$@$"(J$@$/(J$@$^(J$@$G(J$@?M(J$@0Y(J$@E*(J$@$J(J$@$b(J$@$N(J$@$G(J$@$"(J$@$C(J$@$F(J$@!"(J$@$=(J$@$3(J$@$X(J$@$N(J$@5"(J$@B0(J$@$,(J$@5a(J$@$a(J$@$i(J$@$l(J$@$k(J$@$h(J$@$&(J$@$J(J$@<+(J$@A3(J$@E*(J$@EA(J$@E}(J$@E*(J$@6&(J$@F1(J$@BN(J$@$G(J$@$O(J$@$J(J$@$/(J$@!"(J$@;T(J$@L1(J$@$,(J$@@d(J$@$((J$@$:(J$@AO(J$@=P(J$@$7(J$@$F(J$@$$(J$@$/(J$@6&(J$@F1(J$@BN(J$@$@(J$@$+(J$@$i(J$@$G(J$@$"(J$@$k(J$@!#(J$@$7(J$@$+(J$@$b(J$@!"(J$@=!(J$@65(J$@!"(J$@L1(J$@B2(J$@!"(J$@?M(J$@
$@!J(J$@Cp(J6$@!K(J $@!V(J$@%7(J$@%S(J$@%C(J$@%/(J$@!&(J$@%R(J$@%e(J$@!<(J$@%^(J$@%K(J$@%:(J$@%`(J$@$H(J$@$O(J$@!"(J$@<+(J$@B-(J$@$K(J$@8~(J$@$+(J$@$C(J$@$F(J$@$N(J$@8D(J$@?M(J$@$N(J$@H/(J$@E8(J$@$,(J$@2D(J$@G=(J$@$J(J$@$N(J$@$O(J$@!"(J$@$?(J$@$@(J$@8D(J$@?M(J$@$,(J$@;T(J$@L1(J$@$H(J$@$7(J$@$F(J$@!"(J$@$9(J$@$J(J$@$o(J$@$A(J$@<+(J$@N)(J$@E*(J$@$K(J$@0U(J$@;V(J$@7h(J$@Dj(J$@$r(J$@9T(J$@$&(J$@@/(J$@<#(J$@6&(J$@F1(J$@BN(J$@!"(J$@$D(J$@$^(J$@$j(J$@%](J$@%j(J$@%9(J$@$J(J$@$$(J$@$7(J$@6&(J$@OB(J$@9q(J$@$N(J$@<+(J$@3P(J$@E*(J$@<+(J$@N)(J$@E*(J$@;2(J$@2C(J$@
$@!J(J$@Cp(J7$@!K(J Sheldon S. Wolin, Politics and Vision, Boston,1960. $@!J(J$@Hx(J$@7A(J$@E5(J$@CK(J$@!&(J$@J!(J$@ED(J$@4?(J$@0l(J$@!&(J$@M-(J$@2l(J$@90(J$@$[(J$@$+(J$@Lu(J$@!X(J$@?7(J$@Au(J$@HG(J$@!&(J$@@>(J$@2$(J$@@/(J$@<#(J$@;W(J$@A[(J$@;K(J$@!Y(J$@!"(J$@J!(J$@B<(J$@=P(J$@HG(J$@!"(J$@0l(J$@6e(J$@6e(J$@;M(J$@G/(J$@!K(J$@!#(J$@@i(J$@MU(J$@??(J$@!X(J$@%i(J$@%G(J$@%#(J$@%+(J$@%k(J$@!&(J$@%G(J$@%b(J$@%/(J$@%i(J$@%7(J$@!<(J$@$N(J$@CO(J$@J?(J$@!Y(J$@!"(J$@?7(J$@I>(J$@O@(J$@!"(J$@0l(J$@6e(J$@6e(J$@8^(J$@G/(J$@!#(J
$@!J(J$@Cp(J8$@!K(J M. Walzer, The Communitarian Critique of Liberalism, Political Theory, vol. 18, no.1, 1990.
$@!J(J$@Cp(J9$@!K(J C. Taylor, Sources of the Self , Cambridge, Mass., 1989.
$@!J(J$@Cp(J10$@!K(J M. J. Sandel, The Procedural Republic and the Unencumbered Self, Political Theory, vol.12, no. 1, 1984.
$@!J(J$@Cp(J11$@!K(J Politica, A c.1-2.
$@!J(J$@Cp(J12$@!K(J Politica, B 1265a26.
$@!J(J$@Cp(J13$@!K(J$@!!(J$@$?(J$@$H(J$@$((J$@$P(J$@!"(JJ.A.Swanson ( The Public and the Private in Aristotle's Political Philosophy, Ithaca, 1992 ) $@$O(J$@!"(J$@8x(J$@;d(J$@$r(J$@NN(J$@0h(J$@E*(J$@$J(J$@6h(J$@J,(J$@$G(J$@$O(J$@$J(J$@$/(J$@3h(J$@F0(J$@$N(J$@6h(J$@J,(J$@$H(J$@$9(J$@$k(J$@$3(J$@$H(J$@$K(J$@$h(J$@$C(J$@$F(J$@!"(J$@N>(J$@
$@!J(J$@Cp(J14$@!K(J $@A}(J$@ED(J$@;M(J$@O:(J$@!X(J$@ET(J$@;T(J$@!Y(J$@!"(J$@$A(J$@$/(J$@$^(J$@3X(J$@7](J$@J8(J$@8K(J$@!"(J$@0l(J$@6e(J$@6e(J$@;M(J$@G/(J$@!"(J$@*$(J$@>O(J$@!#(J
$@!J(J$@Cp(J15$@!K(J$@!!(J$@%H(J$@%^(J$@%9(J$@$N(J$@6&(J$@DL(J$@A1(J$@;W(J$@A[(J$@$K(J$@$D(J$@$$(J$@$F(J$@$O(J$@0p(J$@3@(J$@NI(J$@E5(J$@!X(J$@%H(J$@%^(J$@%9(J$@!&(J$@%"(J$@%/(J$@%#(J$@%J(J$@%9(J$@$N(J$@6&(J$@DL(J$@A1(J$@;W(J$@A[(J$@!Y(J$@!"(J$@M-(J$@He(J$@3U(J$@!"(J$@0l(J$@6e(J$@O;(J$@0l(J$@G/(J$@$r(J$@;2(J$@>H(J$@!#(J
$@!J(J$@Cp(J16$@!K(J$@!!(J$@$3(J$@$N(J$@E@(J$@$K(J$@4X(J$@$7(J$@$F(J$@$O(J C. J. Nederman, Private Will, Public Justice: Household, Community and Consent in Marsiglio of Padua's Defensor Pacis, The Western Political Quarterly 43, 4 (1990) $@$K(J$@B?(J$@$/(J$@$r(J$@3X(J$@$s(J$@$@(J$@!#(J
$@!J(J$@Cp(J17$@!K(J J. Habermas, Strukturwandel der $@)G(Jfentlichkeit, Frankfurt am Mein, 1990.
$@!J(J$@Cp(J18$@!K(J$@!!(J$@43(J$@@n(J$@9d(J$@;K(J$@!V(J$@8x(J$@6&(J$@@-(J$@$H(J$@%3(J$@%_(J$@%e(J$@%K(J$@%1(J$@!<(J$@%7(J$@%g(J$@%s(J$@!W(J$@!J(J$@!X(J$@%b(J$@%@(J$@%s(J$@$H(J$@%](J$@%9(J$@%H(J$@%b(J$@%@(J$@%s(J$@!Y(J$@=j(J$@<}(J$@!"(J$@K!(J$@N'(J$@J8(J$@2=(J$@
$@!J(J$@Cp(J19$@!K(J$@!!(J$@#R(J$@!&(J$@%I(J$@%%(J$@%*(J$@!<(J$@%-(J$@%s(J$@!V(J$@%j(J$@%Y(J$@%i(J$@%k(J$@$J(J$@6&(J$@F1(J$@BN(J$@!W(J$@!J(J$@9b(J$@66(J$@=((J$@<#(J$@Lu(J$@!K(J$@!X(J$@8=(J$@Be(J$@;W(J$@A[(J$@!Y(Jvol.22-5 $@!"(J$@0l(J$@6e(J$@6e(J$@;M(J$@G/(J$@!"(J$@0l(J$@Fs(J$@;0(J$@!A(J$@0l(J$@Fs(J$@H,(J$@JG(J$@!#(J$@$J(J$@$*(J$@!"(J$@K\(J$@9F(J$@$G(J$@$N(J$@E}(J$@9g(J$@$N(J$@9M(J$@$((J$@J}(J$@$O(J$@%I(J$@%%(J$@%*(J$@!<(J$@%-(J$@%s(J$@$K(J$@Ii(J$@$&(J$@$H(J$@$3(J$@$m(J$@$,(J$@6K(J$@$a(J$@$F(J$@Bg(J$@$-(J$@$$(J$@!#(J
$@!J(J$@Cp(J20$@!K(J M. Oakeshott, On Human Conduct, Oxford, 1975. $@$3(J$@$N(J$@
$@!J(J$@Cp(J21$@!K(J$@!!(J$@$3(J$@$&(J$@$7(J$@$?(J$@
$@!J(J$@Cp(J22$@!K(J$@!!(J$@%"(J$@!<(J$@%l(J$@%s(J$@%H(J$@$N(J$@8x(J$@E*(J$@NN(J$@0h(J$@$K(J$@$O(J$@Fs(J$@$D(J$@$N(J$@H(J$@$i(J$@$9(J$@Hy(J$@8w(J$@$G(J$@$5(J$@$((J$@7k(J$@6I(J$@$O(J$@!"(J$@8x(J$@E*(J$@NN(J$@0h(J$@$N(J$@$/(J$@$i(J$@$Y(J$@$b(J$@$N(J$@$K(J$@$J(J$@$i(J$@$L(J$@$[(J$@$I(J$@$^(J$@$V(J$@$7(J$@$$(J$@8w(J$@$+(J$@$i(J$@@8(J$@$^(J$@$l(J$@$F(J$@$$(J$@$k(J$@!#(J$@!W(J(The Human Condition, Chicago, 1958, p.51)$@!"(J$@8e(J$@
$@!J(J$@Cp(J23$@!K(J$@!!(J$@$3(J$@$&(J$@$7(J$@$?(J$@8x(J$@6&(J$@E*(J$@%U(J$@%#(J$@%j(J$@%"(J$@$r(J$@%"(J$@!<(J$@%l(J$@%s(J$@%H(J$@$K(J$@B((J$@$7(J$@$F(J$@6K(J$@$a(J$@$F(J$@@:(J$@eL(J$@$K(J$@O@(J$@$8(J$@$?(J$@$b(J$@$N(J$@$H(J$@$7(J$@$F(J$@!"(J$@@i(J$@MU(J$@??(J$@!V(J$@0&(J$@$N(J$@35(J$@G0(J$@$H(J$@@/(J$@<#(J$@E*(J$@$J(J$@$k(J$@$b(J$@$N(J$@(!(J$@%"(J$@!<(J$@%l(J$@%s(J$@%H(J$@$N(J$@=8(J$@9g(J$@E*(J$@%"(J$@%$(J$@%G(J$@%s(J$@%F(J$@%#(J$@%F(J$@%#(J$@!<(J$@$N(J$@9=(J$@@.(J$@(!(J$@!W(J$@!X(J$@;W(J$@A[(J$@!Y(J$@Bh(J$@H,(J$@;M(J$@;M(J$@9f(J$@!"(J$@0l(J$@6e(J$@6e(J$@;M(J$@G/(J$@$r(J$@;2(J$@>H(J$@$5(J$@$l(J$@$?(J$@$$(J$@!#(J
$@!J(J$@Cp(J24$@!K(J$@!!(J$@@[(J$@9F(J$@!V(J$@%"(J$@%j(J$@%9(J$@%H(J$@%F(J$@%l(J$@%9(J$@$N(J$@%U(J$@%#(J$@%j(J$@%"(J$@O@(J$@!W(J$@F|(J$@K\(J$@E/(J$@3X(J$@2q(J$@JT(J$@!X(J$@E/(J$@3X(J$@!Y(J$@!"(J$@Bh(J$@;M(J$@!;(J$@9f(J$@!"(J$@0l(J$@6e(J$@6e(J$@!;(J$@G/(J$@!"(J$@;2(J$@>H(J$@!#(J
$@!J(J$@Cp(J25$@!K(J M. C. Nussbaum, Human Functioning and Social Justice in Defense of Aristotelian Essentialism, Political Theory, vol.20 no.2, 1992.
$@!J(J$@Cp(J26$@!K(J $@$3(J$@$N(J$@E@(J$@$K(J$@4X(J$@$7(J$@$F(J$@$O(J$@!"(J$@7*(J$@@4(J$@Ao(J$@!V(J$@8"(J$@NO(J$@!W(J$@!X(J$@8=(J$@Be(J$@$N(J$@@/(J$@<#(J$@;W(J$@A[(J$@!Y(J$@!"(J$@El(J$@3$(J$@Bg(J$@3X(J$@=P(J$@HG(J$@2q(J$@!"(J$@0l(J$@6e(J$@6e(J$@;0(J$@G/(J$@!"(J$@;2(J$@>H(J$@!#(J
$@!J(J$@Cp(J27$@!K(J$@!!(J$@8D(J$@?M(J$@$N(J$@A*(J$@9%(J$@$N(J$@Aj(J$@BP(J$@$K(J$@$b(J$@!"(J$@D6(J$@1[(J$@E*(J$@$J(J$@6&(J$@DL(J$@A1(J$@$H(J$@$$(J$@$&(J$@4Q(J$@G0(J$@$K(J$@$b(J$@4T(J$@85(J$@$5(J$@$l(J$@$J(J$@$$(J$@!"(J$@8x(J$@E*(J$@$J(J$@Mx(J$@1W(J$@!J(J$@$?(J$@$H(J$@$((J$@$P(J$@%J(J$@%9(J$@%P(J$@%`(J$@$,(J$@A0(J$@7G(J$@=q(J$@$G(J$@5s(J$@$2(J$@$k(J$@J#(J$@?t(J$@$N(J$@A1(J$@$N(J$@%j(J$@%9(J$@%H(J$@$,(J$@$3(J$@$l(J$@$K(J$@$"(J$@$?(J$@$k(J$@!K(J$@$r(J$@!"(J$@8D(J$@JL(J$@E*(J$@$J(J$@M_(J$@K>(J$@$H(J$@$b(J$@!"(J$@Ia(J$@JW(J$@E*(J$@$J(J$@M}(J$@@-(J$@G'(J$@<1(J$@$H(J$@$b(J$@0c(J$@$&(J$@;E(J$@J}(J$@$G(J$@G'(J$@CN(J$@$9(J$@$k(J$@G=(J$@NO(J$@$O(J$@!"(J$@8x(J$@6&(J$@E*(J$@$J(J$@@8(J$@$N(J$@Cf(J$@$G(J$@$3(J$@$=(J$@BN(J$@F@(J$@$5(J$@$l(J$@F@(J$@$k(J$@$@(J$@$m(J$@$&(J$@!#(J$@$=(J$@$l(J$@$O(J$@$^(J$@$?(J$@!"(J$@;T(J$@L1(J$@E*(J$@FA(J$@$N(J$@@.(J$@N)(J$@$K(J$@$b(J$@$+(J$@$+(J$@$o(J$@$k(J$@$G(J$@$"(J$@$m(J$@$&(J$@!#(J